Skip to content

Diary of a Burnout Queen

2 tired 2 thrive, 2 stubborn 2 quit

Menu
  • About
  • All Posts
Menu

Writing LGBTQ+ Characters: My Thoughts

Posted on 19th August 202319th August 2023 by Holly Ann

Introduction

This is a topic I’ve been wanting to touch on for a while, but could never quite find the right words.

My first book, My Animus, is an LGBTQ+ story. Why did I decide to write an LGBTQ+ story? Simple. There are a few reasons, truthfully, but the two most prominent ones are the following:

– I remember in high school, my then-best friend pouting over books in the school library. She was a lesbian. When I asked her what was wrong, she sighed and bluntly said “There’s no one in these books I can relate to.”.

– I’ve always believed there needs to be more LGBTQ+ characters in fiction. I love a well-written, believable queer character. I’m not a fan of characters who have been retroactively changed to be queer or characters who feel like they’ve been ripped from the pages of a fourteen-year-old’s DracoXHarry fanfiction. There’s a space for badass queer characters and I aim to fill it, to some degree, with characters that teens and older adults can relate to.

The story jumps between Gavin and his best friend, Ryan. Later in the article, I’ll mention Ryan’s older brother, Saffron. Saffron and Gavin are the protagonists of the sequel. Therefore, wherever there is a quote, it’s from the character being spoken about in that moment — a passage from their point of view.

Gavin Ashmore

The main protagonist, Gavin, is twenty-two years old and has been in denial his entire life. You’ll feel every ounce of his confusion and pain as he realises things and joins the dots in his life. You’ll feel the anger and terror that comes with internalised homophobia, but you’ll also experience the elation and freedom that comes with self-acceptance.

You’ll be there with him every step of the way.

It’s not a comfortable read. It’s not supposed to make you go ‘aww’ and feel cosy. But it’s a true to life journey of inner-reflection and the slow, painstaking journey that comes with self-love.

So let’s talk about Gavin Ashmore. Gavin’s a photography student in his final year of BA Hons Fine Art Photography at Dean School of Art. He’s neurodivergent but has no idea he is, diagnosed with depression and anxiety, taking sertraline but not feeling any changes, and has had issues with self-harm over the years.

Gavin has major body issues. He’s only 5ft2, small and skinny. He hides himself away under baggy hoodies and jumpers, pretending it’s all that ‘alternative’ style, but it’s not — he wears them to hide his wrists. He’s done a good job of that, considering his parents and his brother have never seen his scars.

Funny how I wanted it all to go away and yet all I did was give myself permanent reminders of it all.

He also suffered bulimia. He tried to beg his brother for help but was told ‘bulimia is for girls — grow some balls, dude’. And thus, Gavin learned the brutal reality of masculinity: men don’t get to ask for help. They don’t get to reach out without being told to man up. So it’s no wonder Gavin has gone for years without even questioning his mental health, save for his depression and anxiety. He doesn’t realise he has ADHD, that his chronic overachieving, coupled with that crippling sense of emptiness, isn’t just depression.

The only person I ever told was Lee, and he laughed at me and told me to man up because ‘eating disorders are for lassies’. I wish I was joking. Guess that’s where I learned guys don’t get to ask for help. Wonder how many of my scars could have been avoided.

He keeps telling himself he has no time for relationships — he’s so busy with art school. Truth is, he’s falling into a pit of loneliness that overachieving just can’t fill. He’s desperate to impress his professor for a crumb of validation and praise.

Everything changes when he meets Ryan Speirs, and the pair hit it off, becoming best friends in a short time. Ryan is an American student in his final year of BA Hons Painting. Ryan is everything Gavin needs to fill the void of loneliness. He’s energetic, free-spirited, creative, and the most important thing in Gavin’s eyes, ambitious. He’s the first person to match Gavin’s drive and overachieving, and when the pair team up for a group assignment, their project output and quality are unmatched by the other students.

The pair are inseparable. For the first time in as long as Gavin can remember, he’s happy. He doesn’t fall for Ryan immediately. It takes time and his feelings blossom slowly, despite their friendship being cemented fast. They’re kindred spirits who both seek acceptance in a cold, uncaring world. They become each other’s cheerleaders but it isn’t always sunshine and rainbows, no pun intended. They have their disagreements and moments of tension, as any real friends do. They argue, they fight, but they’ve always got each other’s backs, no matter life throws at them.

We chat random shit, joking about art school and pondering where our careers will take us one day. I open up to Ryan a little about my fears about undeserved praise and that, when art school is over and I’m in the real world, everything is gonna come crashing down around me. He takes a break from his painting work and lies down on his bed, giving me a pep-talk about impostor syndrome. He tells me firmly that I would never have gotten this far if I didn’t deserve to be here. His words strike a deeper chord in me: as he repeats it, I lower my eyes to the fresh bandage on my wrist.

The moment Gavin realises he’s developing feelings for Ryan is the moment his world ends. At least, in his mind, it does. It’s those first few painful steps in a long journey and it’s one that the defiant part of Gavin will walk, despite knowing he has to keep it hidden from his parents. It’s a way to stick his fingers up, not only at his family who have always pressured him, but to the world and society’s expectations too.

Internalised homophobia is an uncomfortable topic and yet it’s one that so many members of the LGBTQ+ community have first-hand experience of. Not many people can accept their homosexuality or bisexuality immediately. Whether or not we realise it, society trains us to view anything outside of heterosexuality as abnormal. For someone to realise they fall outside of that can be earth shattering. It certainly is for Gavin.

It hits me hard. It’s the cold steel of a gun barrel pressed firmly against the back of my neck. There’s no way this is real. I’m not feeling this way. I’m not. I can’t be… No.

Gavin always had a gut feeling that he’s repressed. The further he pushes back, the more his parents and brother push him to find a girlfriend and the more this happens, the more Gavin internalises his own homophobia. He’s always been the golden child, after all — the one with good grades and a good work ethic — so for him to come out as gay makes him feel like a failure. But then again, with Gavin’s ADHD, everything makes him feel like a failure. He’s always wishing deep down for that sense of normality that’s evaded him.

Each line is a dark reminder of every time I’ve seriously questioned my sexuality. It didn’t go well. I cut, and I cut and I bled just to feel ‘normal’ because I didn’t wanna be ‘abnormal’.

After all, everyone around him can plan things, they can handle chores without having a meltdown — he just feels like life is slipping through his fingers and maybe it is. Until Ryan can keep him grounded. Ryan is that feeling of safety and comfort Gavin’s been craving.

And yet, Gavin’s internalised homophobia only applies to himself. He’s not homophobic at all — he has no issue with others being gay. There’s an earlier chapter where he finds out Ryan is gay but kept it from him, fearing a bad reaction, and all Gavin feels towards his friend is compassion.

I can’t even understand why this is terrifying to me. I have no issue with gay people. I support Ryan a hundred per cent so why is it different for me?

But he holds himself to a different standard, a warped standard where he has to be normal. It takes a lot of soul searching for him to realise that being gay is normal. It’s his normal, and that’s all that matters.

Going back to that feeling of losing control, that’s exactly why Gavin lost himself to an eating disorder for a year and a half and yet, no one noticed he was suffering in silence.

…my life was spiralling out of control, but food was something I could control. I used to play off my bruised and bloody knuckles as that old game where you and a buddy would smack a 2p coin into your knuckles. Everyone believed me.

It’s easy to spiral into other issues when you keep denying yourself happiness and acceptance. Gavin’s fear of his own sexuality turned into destructive outlets and damaged his mental health badly. He’s on sertraline for depression and anxiety without ever being asked about the root cause of those issues.

His journey impacts his academic life drastically. Gavin will make mistakes. He will mess things up tremendously. But it’s a learning experience, not only for him, but the reader as well.

Ryan Speirs

For Ryan, he’s a lot more comfortable with his sexuality than Gavin is. He didn’t get a choice. He was outed to the world by the six o’clock news. I can’t divulge any more details without merely stating it involved a violent incident and a criminal case.

Although they did not publicly name Ryan (he was a minor at the time), his older brother Saffron’s band was popular. People connected the dots and figured out who he was. This is why he was tutored and never attended high school. His grades were already slipping and with the added pressures of caring for his homophobic terminal mother, he barely passed his classes.

Ryan was told demons possessed him daily by his mother. The thing is, if someone tells you something enough, you believe it, and Ryan did. He fell into a deep void of severe depression and self-loathing, got a DUI when he wrapped his truck around a tree and tried taking his own life twice. Both attempts were cries for help and, thankfully, people listened this time. Ryan explains his thoughts momentarily when he finds an old blog belonging to Gavin filled with what, at first glance, appear to be homophobic rants. The more Ryan reads, however, the more he realises the truth: Gavin’s been suffering internalised homophobia for a while.

Textbook self-hatred. Oh my God. Each word is like a knife to the gut, but I get it. I absolutely get it. I’ve been there. His agonising words resonate with me so hard, but it’s draining to read them.

He elaborates later in the chapter.

I didn’t wanna be gay either. Mom filled my head with stories about hellfire and brimstone and the eternal torture that awaited me if I so much as looked at another guy. It was something dirty. Something to be ashamed of.

Yet, despite the constant hatred of his religious mother, Ryan clung to his faith when he needed it most. Even before the truth came out about his attacker, he fully believed that justice was waiting for them — if not in this life, then the next. It kept him going — barely — but it was enough. Even to this day, he still takes time to pray when things overwhelm him.

I pray in silence, closing my eyes and feeling the cold wind on my skin. It’s good to be alive, to feel these things, to know that there’s more out there than I’ll ever comprehend. It’s strange. I fear losing power in my own little bubble but I find comfort in the knowledge that I’m powerless in the unimaginable cosmos. I give quiet gratitude for the small things in life. The wet grass under my feet, trees on the horizon, the comfort of Spring bringing renewal with it. I then give thanks for the people in my life, for my professors, my kickboxing buddies, Saffron and, of course, Gavin.

Time changed him. It soothed his wounds, but Ryan knows full well that it’ll never heal them fully. He began painting as an outlet for his emotional trauma and self-medicated with drugs and alcohol. The deeper he got in art, the less he relied on the more destructive methods. Turns out Ryan has a natural talent for art. He’d always been a creative kid, but he dropped art entirely to focus on English and history.

As he reached his late teens, he was finally blossoming into the person he fully believes he was supposed to be: an artist.

Ryan has some deep-rooted trauma about coming out. He’s a survivor with PTSD and is still affected by that night in Los Angeles over a decade ago. He’s trying his best to make the most of his life. His story is a sad one but Ryan fully believes if he wants a happy ending, it’s up to him to achieve it. He’s a hard working and ambitious free-spirit and while he accepts his past and the impact it still has on him, he refuses to let it define him.

Saffron Speirs

It’s not just Gavin and Ryan who are queer. There’s Ryan’s older brother, Saffron, too. Saffron is a biromantic asexual who skirts the nonbinary line gracefully. He doesn’t consider himself a cross-dresser, but he certainly doesn’t give a damn about gendered expectations in fashion.

Vanity is a hard thing to break free from. I think the moment I realised I was dressing up for other people was the moment it all clicked in me. I knew I’d never be happy if I kept trying to fit the stereotypes and moulds people were making for me.

He goes around in massive platform boots and fishnets. His mantra is, if it suits his goth aesthetic, he’s gonna wear it and society be damned. There’s a running joke in the novel where Ryan thinks of Saffron as the most conformist non-conformist. Truth is, Saffron actually isn’t conforming at all. Not to what the world expects him to be and to wear, anyway.

Saffron is perfectly happy identifying as male. He’s comfortable with his gender and how he expresses it, despite living a life where people have constantly told him he must be nonbinary or transgender just because he looks a certain way. Saffy is the type of guy to brush it off, but his confidence is a facade.

Without going into spoiler territory, Saffron and his brother Ryan had the worst time coming out. Saffron was openly flamboyant — after all, his band peaked during the Myspace days when everyone was exploring their gender expression and sexuality without even realising. He was in a relationship with his guitarist and childhood friend, Noah. It was easy for Saffron to hide his relationship — after all, his fanatically religious mother believed computers were poisoned chalices. While the world knew Saffron was queer, his mother was in the dark. He would never tell her. Not by choice, anyway.

Earlier, I said a violent event happened in Los Angeles that outed Ryan. It outed Saffron too. See, until this point, Ryan had kept his sexuality hidden, knowing full well that his mother would go nuclear. Saffron, on the other hand, well, he didn’t exactly care if their mother found out — but only about his own bisexuality. But he kept Ryan’s hidden. He’s always been protective of his little brother. As children and teens, the pair were inseparable, relying on each other for support and validation.

Even today, in Scotland, the pair are best friends. They keep to themselves — Saffron has no friends in the new country, but that’s exactly how he likes it. In his experience, people are too much drama. There are always boundaries they will cross and, as a result, bridges to be burned.

Going back to the aforementioned event, the tl;dr version, again, avoiding spoilers, is that Ryan was attacked and Saffron protected him. It didn’t end well, but Saffron tried his best. The ghosts of the past are always haunting him, threatening to ruin his life even now.

Why am I fronting a Scottish indie band now? Simple. The higher you climb, the further you fall. Our Final Day don’t know why my old band imploded. I don’t know if I’ll ever tell them. All they know is I had it and I lost it. I tell them we just weren’t that popular once we got signed, but one day they might find out the truth.

When the dust finally settled after the event, their mother, instead of acknowledging that both her sons were victims, Ryan especially, blamed everything on Saffron instead. It was his fault demons possessed her little boy. It was his fault the attack took place. It was all because of Saffron. She never considered the psychological damage this event had unleashed on Saffron. She never cared to even think about the trauma and guilt he was suffering through in silence. No. All she cared about was pointing a finger and blaming the devil, and in her eyes, the devil came as Saffron Speirs.

Saffron ended up involuntarily out of their lives. She never visited him. Within a few months, she was diagnosed with terminal cancer and Ryan, just a teenager at the time with no family to lean on, was left to care for her. All the while, she berated him, spat on him, and added to his trauma with stories of hellfire and brimstone. She no longer viewed either of them as her children — they were merely demons in human flesh to her and she wanted them gone.

She would pass away within the year, with no closure for either of her sons. Truth is, Ryan is glad she’s gone, as much as it makes him uncomfortable to admit.

It’s a sad story. And yet, it’s one that is familiar to so many members of the LGBTQ+ community who were raised in religious households. Of course, not all religious people are like this — it’s a small but extreme minority — but it’s something that goes on daily.

And so Saffron, despite his uncaring, almost callous demeanour, is carrying a tremendous weight of guilt and shame deep down that he’s internalised.

There’s never any reconciliation. No peace. It’s a guilt I’ll carry with me to my grave and beyond. You can’t escape your choices. No point in running. Running is tiresome.

His life revolves around his little brother and his constant attempts to atone for not being able to protect him. He doesn’t realise he did protect him; he’s the sole reason the attack ended. He has no idea how much Ryan adores and idolised him. Saffron is Ryan’s hero.

And yet, along with this great sinking feeling of guilt, there’s a part of Saffron that also resents Ryan. He loves his little brother — of course he does. He absolutely dotes on him and yet, there’s that darkness deep in the recesses of his mind that blames Ryan, to some degree, for ruining their lives. And yet, in an ironic twist of fate, the very event that destroyed their lives also gave them both the freedom to move across the globe to Scotland and start their lives anew.

But Saffron has doubts about his place in the community. Asexuals aren’t accepted by some members of the LGBTQ+ community. Bi-erasure is a real thing from both the hetero community and the queer community. Saffron ponders this when attending a pride parade in Glasgow.

Ace people like me, we’re the shadows on the outskirts of the crowd that go unnoticed, and misunderstood by even our tribe. The bi flag is here — that’s nice I guess. Problem is, that’s the other side of my identity that society erases. Dating a girl? Wow, congrats! I must be straight! Dating a guy? Oops, now I’m totally gay, right?

Saffron’s experiences are explored in-depth in the second book, Sparta Will Fall and it’s my hope that you will come away from it with a deeper understanding of asexual individuals and biromantic and gender-nonconforming people.

Writing Queer Characters

While all three characters are queer, they are all complex individuals with their own dreams, regrets and paths to walk. They are three young men who just happen to be part of the LGBTQ+ community but that’s not all there is to them. It’s a part of their identity but it’s not the whole. Just like the community itself, every person within it is a unique individual and no two experiences are the same, even if they are similar.

So many times I have read fiction where the author seems to fixate on the queer part of a character. It becomes all-encompassing, to the point where that’s all there seems to be to the character. In my mind, that does not only the character a disservice, but the entire LGBTQ+ community. Many authors unintentionally oversimplify their queer characters. To me, that can be incredibly harmful, as it can perpetuate stereotyping. A character should be authentic and believable — not merely reduced to how the author imagines a queer character should behave. There are no rules for how an LGBTQ+ character should behave, anyway. They’re diverse and beautiful human beings, even if they live in a fictional world.

It’s important to do your research on the LGBTQ+ community and the struggles they face. If you’re heterosexual and/or cisgender yourself, you can’t just write from your own experiences or what you believe they would face. You do not only yourself but the very community you wish to represent a disservice by writing their experiences through a heterosexual lens.

There are many places you can research. There are countless LGBTQ+ safe spaces on Reddit, Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook, etc. You can reach out to people in your life who are part of the community and ask if they would be willing to talk to you about their experiences and struggles. If you are part of the community yourself, you can write from your own experiences. For cisgender and/or heterosexual writers, absolutely reach out and speak to people. Listen to what they have to say. It’s inevitable that you might make mistakes — you’re human, after all — but the important part is respect. That’s all we ask for: our voices to be heard with respect. You may not understand our experiences but at least you’re willing to listen to us.

That’s not to say heterosexual writers can’t write homosexual, bisexual, pansexual, asexual, etc, characters. It’s not to say cisgender authors can’t have transgender, nonbinary or other gender-nonconforming characters either. They absolutely can. But it’s very important to understand the people you want to represent. I’m not averse to heterosexuals writing queer characters, but so many times, I’m presented with a character that falls flat. There’s no journey, no struggles, and everything feels nice and fluffy. Reality is rarely like that.

LGBTQ+ Fetishisation In Fiction

Which brings me to my final point of contention with queer characters written by straight people: fetishisation. It’s sadly all too common in online writing spaces and seems to be predominantly perpetrated by older straight writers, both male and female. These characters are as thin as a sheet of paper, often Mary Sues or Gary Stus, and the writer will focus mainly on the sexual components of their lives. An uncomfortable truth I’ve come across — especially in my times in the fanfiction communities — is that often these adult writers will sexualise and fantasise about underage characters. Teenage boys or teenage girls ‘finding themselves’, as they often put it.

To be clear, there is nothing wrong with LGBTQ+ stories about underage characters. That’s the time in life where many teens will begin to question and realise their identity, after all. What I do have a problem with is that these stories, as mentioned, hyper-focus on the sexual aspect of the LGBTQ+ relationship. News flash: we don’t exist for your entertainment or your sexual gratification.

See, older writers can (and should) write stories about underage characters. Kids and teens need relatable characters in fiction, one hundred per cent. But my issue lies with the focus being on what goes on behind closed doors. To me, when a story is more about the physical side of a relationship than the emotional side, when there’s no character growth or purpose for exploring that side of things, then the line has been crossed into fetish territory.

Final Thoughts

In closing, I hope this has been an interesting read for you and maybe given you some pause for thought. I fully believe we need more queer characters in fiction, whether they be trans, enby, ace, bi — whatever the character may be. The world is diverse and I love reading about characters who reflect this diversity.

By understanding each other and being empathetic, I believe we can make the world a better place for everyone.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

1 thought on “Writing LGBTQ+ Characters: My Thoughts”

  1. Strain Mary's avatar Strain Mary says:
    26th August 2023 at 2:34 pm

    Brilliantly put and easy to understand. Well written Grem !!

    Loading...
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

© 2026 Diary of a Burnout Queen | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme
%d